¡iºKn¡j ¦ÛEysenck¡]1952¡^¥H来¡A¤ß²zªv疗ªº®ÄªG评ɲ问题¤@ª½¦s¦b争议¡C该¤å¤¶绍¤Fªñ¦~来¦è¤è¤ß²zªv疗领°ì¦³关¤ß²zªv疗¦³®Ä©Êªº²z论发®i©M¬ã¨s设计¡A¦}´N进¤@¨B¬ã¨sªº¤è¦V´£¥X¤F¬Ýªk¡C
¡i关键词¡j ¤ß²zªv疗 药ª«ªv疗 ªv疗关¨t
¤ß²zªv疗领°ì临着许¦h¬D战¡CEysenck¡]1952¡^认为¡G对¤_¯«经¯g来说¡A¤ß²zªv疗¦}¤£¤ñ¦ÛµM²¬·U§ó¦³®Ä[1]¡C这¿E°_¤F学术¬É©M临§É医¥Í¦³关¤ß²zªv疗®ÄªGªº争论¡A«P进¤F¬ã¨sªÌ们ª½±µ进¦æ实证¬ã¨s¡A¥H证©ú¤ß²zªv疗¬O§_¯à够产¥Í¦³¯qªº疗®Ä¡C过¥h¤ß²zªv疗¬ã¨sÉO临§É实践¤§间®t¶Z较¤j¡A临§É医¥Í对¨º¨Ç§ó¦h¬O¥X¤_学术兴½ì¦Ó«D临§É应¥Î¦Ó进¦æªº¬ã¨s«ùÊäºÃ态«×¡Cªñ来¬ã¨sªÌ认识¨ì¤ß²zªv疗¬ã¨s¥²须对临§É实践§ó¨ã¥i±À广©Ê¡A从¦Ó¬ã¨s«点转¦V证©ú¤ß²zªv疗ªº¦X²z©Ê©M¸Ñ释¤ß²zªv疗减轻¤ß²z¯e±wªºÉó¨î¡C¦¹¥~¤ß²z«O°·ªA务Ê^¨t³v¨B«Ø¥ß¥H¤Î¥Íª«ºë¯«¯f学ªº进®i³£对¤ß²zªv疗领°ì´£¥X·sªº¬D战¡A³£n¨D§óºëÚ̦a评¦ô¤ß²zªv疗®ÄªG¡C
1 ¤ß²zªv疗¦³®Ä©Êªº²z论发®i
1¡D1 独¦³¦¨¤À-¦@¦P¦¨¤À¤Î´ç´ç鸟争论
疗®Ä¬ã¨sªº¥Dn问题¬O¡G¨CÏú¤ß²z疗ªk¬O§_¶H¨CÏú药ª«¨º样¦³¨ä独¦³ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À¡H还¬O¡A¤£¦Pªº¤ß²z疗ªk¦³¤@¨Ç对±wªÌ°_§@¥Îªº¦@¦P¦¨¤À¡]common ingredients¡^¡H传统观点认为¤£¦P¤ß²z疗ªk对¤£¦P±wªÌ产¥Í¤£¦P疗®Ä¡A§Y©Ò谓ªº独¦³¦¨¤À¡]unique ingredients¡^²z论¡CµM¦Ó¡A独¦³¦¨¤À²z论没¦³¥O¤H«HªAªº证Õu¤ä«ù¡C¤¸¤ÀªR¤ñ较¤F¤ß²zªv疗¡B¦w¼¢剂©M±±¨î组ªº®ÄªG¤j¤p¡A¤]¥¼发现¤£¦P疗ªkªº®ÄªG¦³显µÛ®tÉÝ¡C¦¹现¶H¡]¤£¦P¤ß²z疗ªk产¥Í¬Û¦P疗®Ä¡^³Q称为¡§´ç´ç鸟论断¡¨¡]dodo bird verdict¡^[2]¡C¤@¯ë认为产¥Í´ç´ç鸟®Ä应¬O错误ªº设计µ¦²¤³y¦¨ªº¡A¦p¡G¥uª`·N¤Fªv疗类«¬¦Ó没¦³±´¹îªv疗变¶q间ªº¥æ¤¬§@¥Î¡F¥u关ª`ªv疗结ªG¡A©¿²¤¤F缓冲变¶q¡]I´º¡B¯f¤H©Ê®æ¯S点¡Bªv疗ªÌªº§Þ¯à¡^¡A¦Ó缓冲变¶qªº¼v响¨Ï¥Ñªv疗ªÌ®tÉÝ©Ò³y¦¨ªºÖît¤ñªv疗类«¬©Ò³y¦¨ªºÖît¤j¡C现¦b¬ã¨sªÌ认为¥²须«视¯S©w¤ß²z疗ªk对¯S©w类«¬ªº¯f¤Hªº¯S©w疗®Ä[3]¡C
¤£¦P¤ß²z疗ªk疗®Ä¬Û¦ü·N¨ý着¦UÏú疗ªk¨ã¦³¦³¯qªº¦@¦P¦¨¤À¡A¥¿¬O这¨Ç¦¨¤À产¥Í¬Û¦üªº疗®Ä¡CLambert©MBergin[4]¦C¥X30个¤£¦P¤ß²z疗ªk¦@¨Éªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À¡]±¡绪´èªn¡Bªv疗关¨t¡B²z论®ÚÕu¡B认ª¾学习µ¥¡^¡C对¦¹¡A¦³¤H认为对¤_¤£¦P§Î¦¡ªº疗ªk¦@¦P¦¨¤À¬O¥²nªº¤]¬O¨¬够ªº¡A¥t¤@¨Ç¤H认为¦@¦P¦¨¤À±`ÉO独¦³¦¨¤À结¦X¦b¤@°_对±wªÌªº进®i¤~¦³实质·N义[5]¡CµM¦Ó¡A¥H¦@¦P¦¨¤À为°ò础¸Ñ释¤ß²zªv疗ªº®Ä¤O¡A¦ü¥G¦^ÁפF¤@个问题¡G¤ß²zªv疗ÉO¨ä¥¦¡]¦pªª师©¾§i¡B劝¼¢©Î«Ø议µ¥¡^¤z预¤â¬q¦³¤°¤\区别©O¡H
1¡D2 过µ{变¶q¤Î过µ{-结ªG¬ã¨s¤èªk
过µ{¬ã¨sªº¥Øªº¬O识别¤ß²zªv疗ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À©M变¤ÆÉó¨î¡C¨ä²z论¨ÌÕu¬O¡G¼W¥[对¤H¤ß²z转变过µ{ªº²z¸Ñ¡A´N¥i¥H§ó¦³®Ä¦a设计©M¤À°tªv疗¤è®×¡C
Orlinsky[3]µ¥¤H´£¥XÉOªv疗®ÄªG¦³关ªº5个过µ{变¶q¡]1¡^ªv疗关¨tªº总Ê^质¶q¡F¡]2¡^ªv疗ªÌ§Þ¯à¡F¡]3¡^±wªÌ¦X§@ÉO对§Ü¡F¡]4¡^±wªÌªº开©ñ©ÊÉO¨¾±s©Ê¡F¡]5¡^ªv疗«ù续时间¡C
Lambert©MHill[3]´£¥X¤T个过µ{-结ªG¬ã¨s¤èªk¡G¡]1¡^ªv疗®ÄªGÉO过µ{变¶q¡]过µ{变¶q¥Nªí¤ß²zªv疗ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À¡^¥X现ªº频数©Î¤ñ¨Ò间ªº¬Û关¡A¡]2¡^运¥Î§Ç¨Ò¤ÀªR来¬ã¨s过µ{变¶q©Ò产¥Íªºª½±µ®ÄªG¡F¡]3¡^¬ã¨s过µ{变较为长´Áªº发®i¼Ò¦¡¡C
Greenbergµ¥¤H运¥Î§Ç¦Cªk来¬ã¨s过µ{-结ªG关¨t¡A¥]¬A¦UÏúÎ`¦X统计¤ÀªR¡A¦p对数线©Ê¼Ò«¬¡B¸ô径¤ÀªR¡B层¦¸线©Ê¼Ò«¬¡F¬ã¨s¥D题¥]¬A¡G处²z¥¼§¹¦¨ªºªv疗¥ô务©M«ìÎ`¤w¯}µõªºªv疗关¨t¡F¤¶绍¦U过µ{变¶q对阶¬q©Ê®ÄªGªº贡献¤Î认ª¾ªv疗ªº过µ{[6]¡C这¨Ç¬O¤ß²zªv疗过µ{¬ã¨sªº·s¤è¦V¡C
1.3 ªv疗关¨t
过¥h10¦~来¡Aªv疗关¨t¡]therapeutic alliance¡A±wªÌ©Mªv疗ªÌ间ªº¤u§@关¨t¡^¤Î¨äÉOªv疗结ªG¤§间关¨tªº¬ã¨sªº¥Dn进®i¬O¡]1¡^¦¨¥\ªºªv疗¤¤对ªv疗关¨tªº¤¤¤ß¨¤¦âªº认ª¾¡]2¡^对ªv疗关¨t§ó为¥þ±©MºëÚ̪º¸Ñ释©M¾Þ§@¡]3¡^对¯à«P进积Ìåªv疗关¨tªºªv疗«e变¶q©M过µ{变¶qªºª`·N¼W¥[¡]4¡^¥[²`对ªv疗关¨t发¥Í变¤Æ©Î¯}µõªºì¦]©M©Ê质ªº²z¸Ñ[7]¡C
ªv疗关¨tªº©w义¦UÉÝ¡A¤£¦P¬ã¨sµ{§Ç强调ªv疗关¨tªº¤£¦P¤è±¡CLuborsky[7]从¤ß²z¤ÀªR¨¤«×对ªv疗关¨t·§©À¤Æ¡A¥L对ªv疗关¨tªº测¶q¥]¬A两³¡¤À¡G±wªÌÊ^验¨ìªv疗ªÌ¬O¦³帮§Uªº¡A±wªÌ·P¨ìªv疗¬O¦X§@ªº§V¤O¡C¦ÓBordin[7]强调ªv疗关¨tªºªx²z论©Ê质¡A认为¤£ºÞªv疗关¨tªº§Î¦¡¦p¦ó¡A³£¥]¬Aªv疗ªÌ©M±wªÌ对¥ô务¤Î¥Ø标ªº¦@识¡A¥H¤Î¬Û¤¬¤§间©M谐©Î¨Ì赖ªº·P¨ü¡C
尽ºÞªv疗关¨tªº©w义¥H¤Î测¶qªv疗关¨tªº¤u¨ã¦UÉÝ¡A¦ý¬ã¨s«Î`证实¤Fªv疗关¨tÉO疗®Ä¤§间ªº¥¿¬Û关关¨t[8]¡C¥Ñªv疗关¨tªº质¶q¥i¥H预测疗®Ä¡A这´N«P¨Ï¬ã¨sªÌ²`¤J¤F¸Ñ¼v响积Ìåªv疗关¨tªº¦]¯À¤Îªv疗«e¤Îªv疗¤¤ªº¦UÏú变¶q¡C¬ã¨s发现[5]¡G¨ã¦³°·±dªº¥Ø标¡B´¶¹M满·NªºªÀ会关¨t¡B¤H际态«×无敌·N©Î¤ä°t±ýªº±wªÌ¡A倾¦V¤_发®i积Ì媺ªv疗关¨t¡C
1.4 疗®Ä标㪺进®i
临§É®ÄªG¡X¡X±wªÌªºÉó¯à转变¨ì«D¯f¤H©Î¥¿±`¤HªºÉó¯àªºS围内¡X¡X¬O³Ì±`¥Îªº疗®Ä标ã[9]¡CTingeyµ¥¤H[ 10]´£¥XªÀ会©Ê®ÄªG验证¤èªk¡A¥Î这Ïú¤èªk¥i¥H区¤À¤£¦Pªº样¥»¡G轻·L¯g状¡]§Y±`态¡^样¥»©M无¯g状¡]§Y°·±d¡^样¥»¡A从¦ÓÚÌ©w临§É¤Wªº«n进®i¡CHoward¤Î¨ä¦P¨Æ[11]´£¥X¤ß²zªv疗ªº进®i发¥Í¦b¤T个¬Û¤¬关联ªº连续阶¬q¤¤¡Gº¥ý±wªÌÊ^验¨ì较¦hªº©¯ºÖ·P¡AµM¦Z¯g状缓¸Ñ¡A³Ì¦ZªÀ会¥Í¬¡¯à¤O±o¥H´£°ª¡C¨ã¦³实证°ò础ªº¯S®íªº疗®Ä标ã¯A¤Î两个维«×¡G⑴ªv疗产¥Íªº¯q处¡A«ü从«ìÎ`¨ì¥¿±`ªº©¯ºÖ·P¡A¨ì获±o°·±dªºªÀ会¥Í¬¡¯à¤O¡F⑵ªv疗¤¤ªº会谈¦¸数¡A«üªº¬O±wªÌ从n¨D较¤Öªº会谈¦¸数¡A¨ìn¨D较¦hªº会谈¦¸数[5]¡C
2 ¬ã¨s设计ªº进®i
2¡D1 ®ø费ªÌ报§i调¬d
¬ü国¡m®ø费ªÌ报§i¡n杂§Ó¡]简称CR¡A1995¡^调¬d¤F2900¦W±o¨ì过¤ß²zªv疗ªº¤H对¤ß²zªv疗ªº¬Ýªk¡A¤j¦h数¤Hªí¥Ü对©Ò±µ¨üªºªv疗¬O满·Nªº¡C¨ä§E³Q调¬dªÌªº¬Ýªk¤À属¤_¥H¤U¤T类¡G¡]1¡^¤£¦P疗ªk®ÄªG¬Û¦P¡]´ç´ç鸟®Ä应¡^¡F¡]2¡^长´Áªv疗¤ñµu´Áªv疗®ÄªG§ó¦n¡F¡]3¡^药ª«¥[¤ß²zªv疗ÉO单独¨Ï¥Î¤ß²zªv疗³£无®Ä[5]¡C
Seligman[12]认为调¬d结ªG显¥Ü¤F¤½众对¤ß²zªv疗ªº¤@¯ë®ÄªG©MɲȫùªÖ©w态«×¡C¦ý§å评ªÌ认为CR调¬d设计¦s¦b问题¡A¦p¡G¥¼设±±¨î组¥H«K±Æ°£¦V§¡È¦^归ªº¦]¤l¡B¦ÛµM²¬·U¦]¤l¡BÉO¤Í¤H¥æ谈©Ò产¥Íªº¼v响ªº¦]¤l¡A¦}¥B¥u¦³4%ìªì样¥»对¤ß²z°·±d调¬d§@¥X¤Ï应¡A¨ä结ªG仅仅从±wªÌ¨¤«×¥X发进¦æ评¦ô[5]¡C鉴¤_¦¹¡ASeligman[12]´£¥X¤@Ïú²z·Q¤Æªº调¬d设计¡G¨¬够¤jªº样¥»¡B«e测¦Z测¤Î¦h维®ÄªG测¶q¡C
2¡D2 随Éó¤Æ临§É试验
随Éó¤Æ临§É试验¡]randomized clinical trial 简称RCT¡^将¬Û对¦P质¡]¯f±¡¬Û¦ü¡^ªº±wªÌ随Éó¤À°t给¤£¦Pªv疗¤è®×¥H«K±±¨î潜¦bªº¤£©ö§Ë²Mªº¦Û变¶q¡CRCT强调内¦b®Ä«×¡]内¦b®Ä«×«ü对变¶q¤§间ªº¦]ªG关¨t§@¥X©úÚ̪º¸Ñ释ªºµ{«×¡^¦]¦Ó关ª`¨ä实证®Ä«×¡]实证®Ä«×«ü²Å¦X实际±¡况ªºµ{«×¡^¡F¦ý¤@¨Ç¬ã¨sªÌ«视¥~¦b®Ä«×¡]¥~¦b®Ä«×«ü¬ã¨s结ªG±À广¨ì¨ä¥¦¦P类±¡况¤Uªºµ{«×¡^¡A认为¥Î¦ÛµM设计¡]naturalistic designs¡A¥Î¥H识别¦ÛµM¦s¦bªº临¬É变¶q¤Î¨ä关¨t¡^¥N´ÀRCT¡A对临§É实践§ó¦³针对©Ê¡C Jacobsonµ¥¤H认为RCT¬ã¨s¯à³q过§ï变¤@¨Ç¦]¯À¡]¦p¡Gªv疗´Á长«×¡Aªv疗ªÌ经验¡A¬O§_«ö·Ó¤â册进¦æªv疗¡Aªv疗§Þ术¬O¨ã¦³¯S®íªº²z论导¦V还¬O§é°Jªº¡^¡A来´£¨ÑÉO临§Éªv疗®ÄªG¬Û关ªº«H®§¡A¦p¡G¬Y¤@¯S®í疗ªk¬O§_¥i¥H运¥Î¤_¬Y¤@¯S®í条¥ó¤U¡A¥H¤Î识别ªv疗ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À[13]¡C
RCT¦s¦b争论¡ASeligman[12]认为¡GRCT对¤_临§ÉI´º¤U实¬I¤ß²zªv疗ªº实证®Ä«×Ú̥߬O¤£¨¬够ªº¡A疗®Ä¬ã¨s©Ò进¦æªº¤ß²zªv疗¤£¯à¥N´À¦b±`规临§É实践¤¤发¥Íªº±¡况¡A¨Ò¦p¡A实际临§É实践¤L¥G¤£«ö·Ó¤â册进¦æ¡A±wªÌÌå¤Ö±wÉݱ`¤Ö见ªº¯f¯g¡Aªv疗¤¤会谈¦¸数¥¼¥[©w¡A¤]¥¼¨Æ¥ý决©w¡A±wªÌ¤]¤£¬O随Éó¤À°tªv疗¤èªkªº¡CHoward[14]µ¥¤H´£¥X¡A随Éó¤Æ«Ü¤Ö¯à够µ¥¤À组¡A¤]¤L¥G¤£¯à±±¨î±wªÌ-ªv疗¤èªk¤§间ªº¥æ¤¬§@¥Î¡A从¦Ó随Éó¤Æ实验设计±`变¦¨¤£¯à¥R¤À±±¨î内¦b无®Ä·½ªºã实验设计¡C
2¡D3 剂¶q®ÄªG¬ã¨s
¤j¦h数疗®Ä¬ã¨s来¦Û¤_剂¶q¼Ò«¬[15]¡C剂¶q®ÄªG设计¡]dose-effect studies¡^¡]§Yªv疗¤¤会谈ªº数¶qÉO疗®Ä¤§间关¨tªº¬ã¨s¡^¤w证实剂¶q¡]§Yªv疗¤¤会谈ªº¦¸数¡^ÉO±wªÌ¦³进®i©Î¥¿±`¤Æªº¥i¯à©Ê§e¥¿¤ñ¡A¦}¦b较°ª剂¶q¤ô¥±¡况¤U¯f±¡Î`发ªº¥i¯à©Ê减¤Ö¡C剂¶q®ÄªG¬ã¨s¥Î¥H评ɲ临§ÉI´º¤U¤ß²zªv疗ªº®ÄªG¡C剂¶q®ÄªG¬ã¨sªí©ú[5]¡G¡]1¡^®ÚÕu¸ó¦U会谈´Á¡]sessions¡^ªº¤ß²z¯g状ªº进®i²v¡A¥i¥H将¤ß²z¯g状¦E¤À为3个¤Ï应类«¬¡G«æ©ÊW恼©Î´dµh«¬¡]acute distress¡^¡A¨ä进®i³Ì§Ö¡A©Ê®æ«¬¡]characterological¡^W恼©Î´dµhªº进®i³ÌºC¡A¦Ó进®i¬É¤_¤GªÌ¤§间ªº¬OºC©Ê¡]chronic¡^W恼©Î´dµh¡A¤]称为¤¤间«¬¡]intermediate¡^¡F¡]2¡^对¤_¤j¦h数临§É¯g状¡A16个会谈´Á¦Ü¤Ö´£¨Ñ¤F50%«ìÎ`±`态Éó¯àªº¥i¯à©Ê¡A26¦Ü28个会谈´Á´£¨Ñ¤F75%ªº¥i¯à©Ê¡C
剂¶q®ÄªG¬ã¨sÉORCT¥i¥H´£¨Ñ±wªÌªv疗进®iªº总Ê^«H®§¡A¦ý¨ãÊ^¨ì个别±wªÌ来说¡A¸ó¦U会谈´Áªº疗®Ä进®i¼Ò¦¡¦}¤£¬O线©Êªº¡A¦]¦¹¦b临§É实践¤¤ªv疗ªÌ应当随时关ª`±wªÌªº当«e状况¡A¦}ÚÌ认该状况¬O§_¬O对©Òªö¥Îªºªv疗¤è®×ªº¤Ï应[16]¡C为¦¹¡A¬ã¨sªÌ们运¥Î剂¶q®ÄªG设计¡A¸ò踪记录¦b¦U会谈´Á±wªÌ´Â¦V«¤j临§É进®iªº发®i变¤Æ¡A¦}对疗®Ä进¦æ测¶q¡CHowardµ¥¤H[14]¨î§@¤F±wªÌªº¯g状å±图¡A¦}运¥Î层¦¸线©Ê¼Ò«¬¡A®ÚÕu±wªÌªv疗«eªº临§É¯S点¼Ò拟¥X±wªÌ©Ò´Á±æªºªv疗进®i过µ{¡C±wªÌªº实际ªv疗进®i¡]¥Ñ剂¶q®ÄªG设计测©w¡^¥iÉO¨ä´Á±æªº进®i¤ñ较¡A¦}¥H¦¹§@为决µ¦ªº标ã¡F¤@¥¹±wªÌªº¤Ï应´Â¦V¤£²z·Qªº¤è¦V发®i¡A´N¥i¥H§Y时调¾ãªv疗¤è®×¡C
2.4 §Þ术迁²¾¼Ò«¬
Shadish¤Î¦P¨Æ´£¥X§Þ术迁²¾¼Ò«¬[17]¡]technology transfer model¡^¡A¥i将¬ì学发现¤Þ¤J临§É实践¡C¦¹¼Ò«¬¥]¬A¤个阶¬q¡]1¡^¬YÏú¤ß²zªv疗ªº¥i¦æ©Ê©M风险ªº试点测试¡F¡]2¡^¦b随Éó临§É试验¤¤评¦ô从¦Ó¤F¸Ñ¬YÏúªv疗¬O§_¦b¯u实条¥ó¤U¦³®Ä¡F¡]3¡^对¯S®í¸sÊ^进¦æªv疗¡A¤F¸Ñªv疗对¯f¦]¤£¦Pªº±wªÌ©Ò°_ªº§@¥Î¡F¡]4¡^实¬Iªv疗ªººt¥Ü¬ã¨s¡A¦}让¤½众进¦æ评¦ô¡F¡]5¡^评¦ô临§É实践¤¤ªº¤ß²zªv疗[5]¡C
2¡D5 ¤p结
¥Ø«e疗®Ä¬ã¨s±临ªº¥Dn问题¬O[18]¡G¡]1¡^þ¤@Ïú¤ß²zªv疗¥i¥H¹³¨ä²z论´yzªº¨º样¦b±±¨î条¥ó¤U°_§@¥Î¡H¡]2¡^þ¤@Ïú¤ß²zªv疗¥i¥H¦b实际ªº临§ÉI´º¤U¤u§@¡H¡]3¡^¥ÎPaul¡]1967¡^¦³¦Wªº±wªÌµJ点问题¡]patient-focused question¡^来说¡§þÏú¤ß²zªv疗¦bþÏú±¡况¤U对þÏú¯f¤H³Ì¦³®Ä¡H¡¨¡]4¡^þÏú¤ß²zªv疗®Ä²v³Ì°ª¡H
RCT¥i¥H¦^µª¡]1¡^¤¤ªº问题¡C对¡]2¡^来说¡A剂¶q®ÄªG¬ã¨s¯à够发现ÉO临§ÉI´º¬Û¦üªº¡B¥Ñ¤£¦P¤èªkªv疗ªº±wªÌ¸ó¦U会谈´Áªº疗®Ä¡C运¥Î剂¶q®ÄªG设计¡A对个别±wªÌªºªv疗类«¬¤Î剂¶q¤Ï应¼Ò¦¡进¦æ¤À组¡A¥i¥H¦^µª¡]3¡^¤¤Paulªº±wªÌµJ点问题¡C¦³关¡]4¡^¡AºÞ²z«O°·ªA务¡]managed health care¡^©M¥Íª«ºë¯«¯f学³£ªÖ©w药ª«ªv疗¤ñ¤ß²zªv疗§ó§Ö¡B§ó«K©y¡B§ó¦³®Ä¡F¦ý对¤_¦UÏú¤ß²z疗ªk来说¡A运¥Î剂¶q®ÄªG设计¥i¥H´£¨Ñ¦UÏú±wªÌ进®i²v«ü数¡A³q过±wªÌ¯g状发®i变¤Æªº连续¦±线¦Ó«D¤Ö数¤L个¯g状变¤Æªº¤À数来§P©wþÏú¤ß²zªv疗较¦³®Ä¡AþÏú³Ì¦³®Ä[5]¡C
3 ªv疗§Þ术ªº¬ã¨s进®i
ªv疗§Þ术¤è±ªº¬ã¨s进®i¥]¬A¡]1¡^¤ß²zªv疗ÉO药ª«ªv疗¤§间ªº关¨t¡]2¡^¤ß²zªv疗¾ã¦X¥D义©M§é°J¥D义ªº·§©À¤Æ¥H¤Î¥¦们§@为¤w³Q©Ó认ªº¤ß²zªv疗Ïú类ªº¨¤¦â问题[5]¡C
3¡D1 ¤ß²zªv疗ÉO药ª«ªv疗
随着现¥Nºë¯«药ª«学¤£断发®i¡Aºë¯«药ª«Ïú类¼W¦h¡A¶V来¶V¦hªº±wªÌ结¦X药ª«进¦æ¤ß²zªv疗¡C¦³¥²n¤F¸Ñ药ª«ªv疗ÉO¤ß²zªv疗¤§间ªº疗®Ä®tÉݤΥ椬§@¥Î¡A从¦Ó将¤ß²z«O°·ªA务ªº®ÄªG³Ì¤j¤Æ¡C¤ß²zªv疗ÉO药ª«ªv疗ªº¤ñ较¬ã¨s调¬d¤Fªv疗§í§ÉOÕa®£»Ù碍ªº®ÄªG[5]¡A¬ã¨s¤¤¤@¯ë¥H认ª¾¦æ为ªv疗¥Nªí¤ß²zªv疗¡C
¬ü国国®a¤ß²z°·±d¬ã¨s©Ò§í§ªv疗¦X§@¬ã¨sµ{§Ç¡]简称TDCRP¡A1989¡^将250¦W单¬Û§í§±wªÌ随Éó¤À¬£¨ì¥|Ïú条¥ó¤§¤@¡G认ª¾¦æ为ªv疗¡]CBT¡^¡A¤H际ªv疗¡]IPT¡^¡A¤þ«}嗪¡]¤@Ïú¤T环§Ü§í§剂¡^¥[临§ÉºÞ²z¡]IMI-CM¡^¡A药ª«¦w¼¢剂¥[临§ÉºÞ²z¡]PLA-CM¡^¡C结ªG¦p¤U¡G¡]1¡^¥|Ïú条¥ó¤U³£¦³进®i¡]2¡^¥ô¦ó¤@Ïú¤ß²zªv疗¤]¤£¤ñ¥t¤@Ïú§ó¦n¡]3¡^对©Ò¦³±wªÌ来说¡A°ß¤@«nªº®tÉÝ产¥Í¦bIMI-CMÉOPLA-CM¤§间¡]4¡^IMI-CM©MIPT¤ñPLA-CM产¥Íªº进®i§ó¤j¡A¡]5¡^IMI-CM¤@¯ë来说¤ñ¨ä¥¦¤èªk产¥Í§ó§Öªº疗®Ä¡C对¦¹¬ã¨s结ªG¦s¦b争议¡AJacobsonµ¥¤H认为CBT对严®æ进¦æ药ª«ªv疗ªº门诊¯f¤H¬O¥i¦æªº选择¡CElkinµ¥¤H认为©|¤£¯à±o¥X结论¡A¦ÓKlein认为CBT¤£¬O¤@Ïú¦³®Äªºªv疗¤èªk[5]¡C
¤ß²zªv疗对Õa®£»Ù碍±wªÌªº疗®Äɬ¤_药ª«ªv疗¡CClarkµ¥¤H[5]发现CBT¡]认ª¾ªv疗¥[¤W¤f头¤W¦Û§Ú©ÜÅS¡^产¥Íªº²¬·U²v¡]90%¡^°ª¤_¤þ«}嗪¡]55%¡^©M应¥ÎªQ¦¢疗ªk¡]50%¡^¡CÉO¤§¬Û¦ü¡AKlosko¤Î¨ä¦P¨Æ[5]报§i对Õa®£»Ù碍ªº²¬·U²v来说¡ACBT¡]²¬·U²v为87%¡^¤ñ¨ä¥¦药ª«¦w¼¢剂¡]²¬·U²v为36%¡^°ª¡A¦Óªü´¶Ðü仑¡]²¬·U²v为50%¡^¡]¤@Ïú¦w©w剂¡^ÉO¦w¼¢剂¬Û¤ñ©|¥¼发现®tÉÝ¡C¬ã¨s证©úCBT¯à¦³®Ä预¨¾Î`发¡A¦Ó许¦h¨Ï¥Î药ª«ªv疗ªº±wªÌ¦b°±药¦Z¯f±¡Î`发[5]¡C
3¡D2 ¯S®í²z论导¦Vªº疗ªk-²z论¾ã¦X
¶V来¶V为¤H©Ò±µ¨üªº观点¬O¡G¥Ñ¬Y¨Ç¥Dn¤ß²z疗ªk长´Á¤ä°tªº§½±¤w结§ô¡C¤ß²zªv疗§Þ术选择¤è±¦s¦b3Ïú倾¦V¡G⑴选择¦³¯S®í²z论«ü导ªº¤ß²z疗ªk¡A¦¹Ïú疗ªk¨ã¦³独¦³ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À¡A¦b¯S®í¦Ó连续ªº¤z预¤¤实¬I¡A¤ñ¦p¤ß²z¤ÀªR©Î¦æ为疗ªk¡C⑵选择¾ã¦X¥D义¡]integrationism¡^ªº疗ªk¡A¦¹Ïú疗ªk©â¨ú¨CÏú²z论°²设ªº¬¡©Ê¦¨¤À¡A¦}试图将¨ä归¤_单¤@ªº¡B§ó¤@¯ë©Êªº²z论®Ø¬[¤§¤U¡C¦ý¬O¡A¥Ø«e´N¤°¤\¬O¾ã¦X¥D义©|¥¼达¦¨¦@识¡C¤@¯ë认为¾ã¦X¤@词§óÓì¥Î¤_«D实践©Êªº¡A¨ã¦³§ó为统¤@ªº²z论¤ÆÊ^¨tªºªv疗¤èªk[19]¡C¦Ó¥B¡A许¦h¬ã¨sªÌ认为¾ã¦X¥D义疗ªkªºªv疗®ÄªG¨ì©³¦p¦ó¦³«Ý¬ã¨s来证©ú¡C⑶§é°J¥D义¡]eclecticism¡^ªº疗ªk¡A¥¦¤£属¤_¬Y¤@个²z论学¬£¡A¦Ó¬O趋¦V¤_¦UÏú¤èªk¡B²z论ªºÝ¦¬¦}»W¡A§é°J¥D义ªÌ针对±wªÌªº¨ãÊ^±¡况¡A选择应¥Î²z论¤W¤£¦Pªº¤z预¤è¦¡进¦æªv疗[5]¡C
¾ã¦X¥D义©M§é°J¥D义³v渐¦¨为ªv疗§Þ术ªº¥D导发®i¤è¦V¡C§ó¦hªºªv疗ªÌ§â¦Û¤v¬Ý§@¬O§é°J¥D义ªº¡C这ªí©ú²z论ªº¤£断§¹µ½ÉO¤èªkªº¤£断§ï进¬Oªv疗发®iªº¦ÛµM趋势¡A¤]ªí©ú¤F¤ß²zªv疗领°ì¤¤实¨Æ¨D¬O¦a对«Ý²z论¤Î¤èªkªº态«×¡C这Ïú趋势¥²将导P对¤ß²zªv疗²z论¤Î¤èªkªº¬ì学¬ã¨s¨ú±o进¤@¨B发®i[19]¡C
4 疗®Ä¬ã¨s¥Ø«e¦s¦bªº问题
¥Ñ¥H¤W¤¶绍¥i¥H¬Ý¥X¤ß²zªv疗®ÄªG评ɲ领°ì¦s¦b着积Ì媺转变¡A³v渐§Î¦¨¤F疗®Ä评ɲÊ^¨t¡A·sªº疗®Ä¬ã¨s设计¥¿¦b¥X现¡A´¦¥Ü¥X·sªº«H®§¡A¦Ó¤w经Ú̥ߪº¬ã¨s¤èªk¡]¦pRCT¡^¦b应¥Î¤¤变±o§ó¥[¦¨¼ô¡C随着¬ã¨sªÌ§â¤ß²zªv疗疗®Ä评ɲªº·s¤èªk运¥Î¤_临§É实践¡A这¤@领°ì¥²将¥X现¤jªº¬ð¯}¡C¦ý¬O¡A疗®Ä评ɲ领°ì¤]¦s¦b¥H¤U¤@¨Ç问题[5]¡G¡]1¡^实证疗®Ä检验¤£«ê当¦a强¤Æ¤Fªº¤ß²zªv疗ªº药ª«¤Æ¡F¡]2¡^±Æ°£¤Fã实验¬ã¨s¡A¥un¨D随Éó临§É实验¡A©ÎªÌn¨D¤j¶qªº单独®×¨Ò设计¬ã¨s¡A这¦}¤£¯à¥Nªí实际实¬Iªº¤ß²zªv疗¡F¡]3¡^运¥ÎDSM-IV标ã对±wªÌ进¦æ¤À类¦s¦b®Ä«×©M«H«×问题¡A©Ò´£¨Ñªº±wªÌ¤À类过¤ÀÉÝ质¡]4¡^¤j¦h数运¥Î¤_实际临§É±¡¹Ò¤¤ªº¤ß²z疗ªk没¦³¦C¤J疗®Ä检验¦W单¡]¦p¡G§é°J疗ªk¡B长´Á¤ß²z动¤Oªv疗µ¥¡^¡C
随着§Ú国经济ªº发®i¡A¤ß²z«O°·¶V来¶V为¤H们©Ò关ª`¡C¦b¤ß²z«t询©Mªv疗业³v渐规S¤Æªº¦P时¡A¥²µMn¨D对¤£¦P¤ß²z疗ªkªº疗®Ä进¦æ实证检验¡C¥»¤å¤¶绍¤F国¥~¦³关¤ß²zªv疗¦³®Ä©Ê¬ã¨sªº²z论©M¤èªkªº进®i¤Î¦s¦bªº问题¡A¦®¦b为§Ú国¤ß²zªv疗疗®Ä评ɲ领°ìªº发®i©M¬ã¨s´£¨Ñ参¦Ò¡C
¡i参¦Ò¤å献¡j
[1]Strupp H. Resesrch, practice, managed care. Psychotherapy, 1997, 34: 91-94
[2]Wampold B E.Methodological problems in identifying efficacious psychotherapies.Psychothrapy Research,1997,7:21-43
[3]Giles T R. Handbook of Effective Psychotherapy. New York
lenum,1993
[4]Bergin A E, Garfield S L. Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behavior Change. New York:Wiley, 1994
[5]Kopka S M, Lueger R J, Howard K I et al. Individual psychotherapy outcome and progress research. Annual Review of Psychology,1999,50: 441-469
[6]Greenberg L S¡ANewman F L. An approach to psychotherapy change process research¡Gintroduction to the special section. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,1996,64:435-438
[7]Horvath A O, Greenberg L S. The Working Alliance:Theory, Research, and Practice. New York:Wiley & sons, 1994
[8]Krupnick J L, Sotsky S M, Simmens S et al. The role of the therapeutic alliance in psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy outcome:findings in the National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1996,64:532-539
[9]Jacobson N S, Follette W C, Revenstorf D. Psychotherapy outcome research¡Gmethods for reporting variability and evaluating clinical aignificance. Behavior Therapy, 1984,15:336-352
[10]Tingey R C, Lambert M J, Burlingame G M et al. Assessing clinical significance¡Gproposed extensions to method. Psychotherapy Research, 1996,6¡G109-123
[11]Howard K I, Lueger R J,Maling M S et al.A phase model of psychotherapy¡Gcausal mediation of outcome. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,1993,61¡G878-685
[12]Seligman M E P.The effectiveness of psychotherapy¡Gthe Consumer Reports study. American Psychology,1995,50¡G965-974
[13]Jacobson N, Christensen A.Studying the effectiveness of psychotherapy:how well can clinical trials do the job? American Psychology, 1996, 51:503-508
[14]Howard K I, Moras K, Brill P L et al. Evaluation of psychotherapy: efficacy, effectiveness, and patient progress. American Psychologist, 1996, 51:1059-1064
[15]Howard K I, Kopta S M, Krause M S et al.The dose-effect relationship in psychotherapy. American Psychologist ,1986, 41:159-164
[16]Barkham M, Stiles W B, Shapiro D A.The shape of change in psychotherapy:longitudinal assessment of personal problems. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology,1993,61:667-677
[17]Shadish W R, Matt G E, Navarro A M et al. Evidence that therapy works in clinically representative conditions. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 1997, 65: 355-365
[18]Goldfried M R, Greenberg L S, Marmar C.Individual psychotherapy:process and outcome. Annual Review of Psychology, 1990, 41: 659-688
[19]钱铭©É. ¤ß²z«t询ÉO¤ß²zªv疗. ¥_¨Ê¡G¥_¨Ê¤j学¥Xª©ªÀ,1994.275-282
http://journal.9med.net/qikan/article.php?id=298691